What to Do If the PIO Does Not Respond to Your RTI Application?

A Public Information Officer (PIO) who ignores an RTI application is not simply being slow — the RTI Act treats non-response as a failure with consequences. This guide explains what accountability mechanisms exist for an unresponsive PIO and how to use them effectively.

If your main question is about the 30-day deadline and how to count it, see What to do if your RTI application is not answered within 30 days.

The short answer

You have two remedies, which serve different purposes and can be used together:

  1. First Appeal under Section 19(1) — to obtain the information. This is the route that can lead to a direction to disclose.
  2. Complaint under Section 18(1) — to have the Information Commission inquire into the PIO’s failure, which may result in a penalty under Section 20 and a recommendation for disciplinary action.

The PIO’s legal duties

  • Section 5(3) — a PIO must deal with requests and render reasonable assistance to persons seeking information.
  • Section 5(4)–(5) — a PIO may seek the assistance of any other officer, and that officer is treated as a PIO for the purposes of liability.
  • Section 6(1) — where a request cannot be made in writing, the PIO must render reasonable assistance to reduce it to writing.
  • Section 7(1) — decide within 30 days (48 hours for life or liberty).
  • Section 7(8) — if rejecting, communicate reasons, the appeal period and the appellate authority’s particulars.

Why PIOs fail to respond — and what it means for you

Common cause What you should do
Application sent to an officer who is not the designated PIO It should still be forwarded internally, but check the public authority’s published PIO list and consider re-sending to the correct PIO
Information held by another office of the same authority The PIO may seek assistance from that officer under Section 5(4); non-response is still the PIO’s responsibility
Information held by another public authority The PIO should have transferred it within 5 days under Section 6(3); failure to transfer can be raised in appeal
Application or fee lost or not recorded Your proof of delivery and payment becomes crucial
Deliberate non-response Appeal and complaint; seek penalty

Remedy 1: The First Appeal

File the First Appeal with the First Appellate Authority (FAA) — an officer senior to the PIO — generally within 30 days after the response period expires. Ask for: a direction to supply the information; supply free of charge under Section 7(6); and, where relevant, transfer of any part held by another authority. See RTI First Appeal assistance.

Remedy 2: The Section 18 complaint

Section 18(1) requires the Central or State Information Commission to receive and inquire into a complaint from any person who, among other things:

  • could not submit a request because no PIO was appointed, or an Assistant PIO refused to accept it (clause (a));
  • was refused access to information (clause (b));
  • was not given a response within the time limit (clause (c));
  • was required to pay an unreasonable fee (clause (d));
  • believes they were given incomplete, misleading or false information (clause (e));
  • has any other grievance relating to requesting or obtaining access (clause (f)).

The Commission has certain powers of a civil court while inquiring (Section 18(3)), including summoning persons and requiring production of documents.

Important limitation: the Supreme Court has held that, while deciding a Section 18 complaint, the Commission cannot direct the public authority to disclose the information. Disclosure is ordered in an appeal under Section 19. Do not rely on a complaint alone if you want the information.

Penalty on the PIO — how it works

  • Under Section 20(1), if the Commission finds that the PIO, without reasonable cause, refused to receive an application, did not furnish information within time, malafidely denied it, knowingly gave incorrect, incomplete or misleading information, destroyed information or obstructed its furnishing, it shall impose a penalty of ₹250 per day until the application is received or information furnished, subject to a maximum of ₹25,000.
  • The PIO must be given a reasonable opportunity of being heard, and the burden of proving that they acted reasonably and diligently is on the PIO.
  • Under Section 20(2), the Commission may recommend disciplinary action against the PIO for persistent or specified defaults.
  • The penalty is paid by the PIO, not to the applicant. Compensation for loss or detriment suffered by the applicant is a separate power under Section 19(8)(b).

Step-by-step approach

  1. Confirm the date of receipt and that the period has expired.
  2. Check the RTI Online status or post for a missed reply or transfer letter.
  3. File the First Appeal within 30 days.
  4. If the PIO’s conduct warrants inquiry, file a Section 18 complaint with the appropriate Commission, attaching proof of filing and non-response.
  5. If the FAA also fails, file a Second Appeal within 90 days and ask the Commission to consider penalty under Section 20.

Example (hypothetical)

Meera files an RTI application with a Central ministry on RTI Online. Thirty-five days later the status still shows “Request Received”. She files a First Appeal online the same week. The FAA directs the PIO to reply within 15 days; the PIO again does not reply. Meera files a Second Appeal with the Central Information Commission and, in it, requests that penalty proceedings be initiated. At the hearing the PIO must show reasonable cause for the delay.

Documents required

  • RTI application and proof of delivery and fee payment.
  • RTI Online status screenshots, if filed online.
  • First Appeal and any FAA order, for a Second Appeal.

Common mistakes

  • Complaining to the PIO’s superior informally instead of filing a statutory appeal.
  • Expecting the penalty to be paid to you.
  • Assuming a penalty is automatic — the Commission decides after hearing the PIO.
  • Choosing the wrong Commission (Central vs State).

Frequently asked questions

Can I file a complaint and an appeal at the same time?

Yes. They serve different purposes. The appeal seeks the information; the complaint seeks an inquiry into the failure.

Is there a time limit for a Section 18 complaint?

The Act does not prescribe one, but prompt filing is advisable and the Commission’s rules and practice may affect how a delayed complaint is treated.

Does the PIO’s non-response mean I will get the information?

Not necessarily. The public authority may still claim exemptions at the appeal stage, though it must justify any denial.

Need help?

We can prepare your First Appeal, Section 18 complaint or Second Appeal.

Apply for RTI Assistance · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com

Official references

This article provides general information about the Right to Information Act, 2005 and is not legal advice. RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any government body.

Author: RTI Lawyers Editorial Team · Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026