The short answer
Prepare a concise document (often 2–5 pages) that sets out: the background in a few lines; a table of each point sought, the reply and the outstanding deficiency; your legal arguments on any exemption; and the precise relief sought. Attach an indexed set of documents. Send it to the Commission and, where required, to the public authority before the hearing.
Recommended structure
- Heading — Commission, appeal or complaint number, parties, hearing date.
- Summary — two or three sentences on what is in dispute.
- Chronology — application, reply, First Appeal, FAA order, Second Appeal, with dates.
- Status table — point, information sought, reply, outstanding issue.
- Submissions on law — for each disputed point: why it is “information” held by the authority; why the exemption claimed does not apply or applies only partly; severability (Section 10); public interest (Section 8(2)) where relevant; burden on the PIO (Section 19(5)).
- Penalty and compensation — only if the facts support delay or obstruction without reasonable cause, or loss.
- Relief — specific directions sought.
- Index of documents.
Writing tips
- Use the authority’s own documents to show that records exist.
- Quote statutory text accurately; cite any decisions with full, verified citations.
- Do not expand the original request.
- Stay factual and respectful.
Responding to the public authority’s written reply
If the authority files a reply before the hearing, prepare a short rejoinder addressing each new point — especially new exemptions or claims that records are unavailable.
At the hearing
- Have the submissions and documents open.
- Summarise the outstanding points in a minute or two.
- Answer the Commission’s questions directly.
- Note any directions given orally and the date for compliance.
Common mistakes
- Long narratives about the underlying dispute.
- Unsupported allegations against officers.
- Unverified case citations.
Frequently asked questions
Are written submissions compulsory?
No, but they help the Commission and ensure your points are on record, particularly in short video hearings.
Can I submit documents not filed with the appeal?
Generally yes, if relevant; follow the Commission’s instructions in the hearing notice.
Related
Apply for RTI Assistance · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com
Official references
- Right to Information Act, 2005 — India Code
- Central Information Commission — cic.gov.in
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any government body.
Author: RTI Lawyers Editorial Team · Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026