How to File an RTI First Appeal Under Section 19(1)?

The First Appeal is the first statutory remedy against an unsatisfactory RTI response. It is internal to the public authority, quick, and — for Central authorities — free. Doing it properly also sets up any later Second Appeal.

The short answer

Address the appeal to the First Appellate Authority (FAA) — an officer senior in rank to the PIO in the same public authority — within 30 days of receiving the PIO’s decision or of the expiry of the response period. Set out the application, the reply, your grounds and the relief you want, attach copies, and file it online (where available) or by post or hand.

Who can appeal and when

Under Section 19(1), any person who does not receive a decision within the time specified, or is aggrieved by a PIO’s decision, may appeal. Typical triggers: no reply, rejection, partial or incomplete information, unreasonable fee demand, or a reply that does not match the request.

Step-by-step

  1. Find the FAA — the PIO’s reply should name the FAA (Section 7(8)(iii)). Otherwise check the authority’s RTI page or Section 4 disclosures.
  2. Calculate the deadline — 30 days from receiving the decision, or from the expiry of the PIO’s period if there was no decision.
  3. Draft the appeal — include:
    • appellant’s name and address;
    • particulars of the RTI application (date, registration number, PIO);
    • particulars of the PIO’s reply (date, reference), or a statement that none was received;
    • brief facts;
    • grounds of appeal, point by point;
    • relief sought;
    • list of enclosures; signature and date.
  4. File it:
    • RTI Online — for applications filed on the portal to Central authorities, use “Submit First Appeal” with your registration number.
    • Post or hand — address to the FAA; keep tracking or a dated acknowledgement.
  5. Fee — none under the Central rules; check State rules.
  6. Wait for the decision — the FAA should decide within 30 days, extendable to 45 days with recorded reasons (Section 19(6)).
  7. Next step — if the FAA fails to decide or you are still aggrieved, file a Second Appeal within 90 days.

Writing effective grounds

Good grounds are specific and tied to the Act. Examples:

  • “No decision was given within 30 days; the request is deemed refused under Section 7(2).”
  • “Point 3 was rejected under Section 8(1)(j) without reasons, contrary to Section 7(8).”
  • “The information sought at point 2 relates to official decisions and can be supplied after severing any personal details under Section 10.”
  • “The reply at point 4 does not address the records requested.”

Relief to ask for

  • A direction to supply specific points.
  • Supply free of charge where time limits were not met (Section 7(6)).
  • Inspection of records (Section 2(j)) where volume is an issue.
  • Transfer of points held by another authority (Section 6(3)).

Hearings

Some FAAs decide on papers; others call the appellant and PIO. If called, bring copies of everything and keep to the points in the application.

Common mistakes

  • Addressing the appeal to the PIO.
  • Introducing new questions.
  • Filing late without explaining the delay.
  • Omitting copies of the application and reply.

Frequently asked questions

Can I appeal if the PIO supplied the information late?

Yes, if it is incomplete or you were charged despite delay. Section 7(6) requires free supply where time limits are not met.

Can the FAA impose a penalty?

No. Penalties under Section 20 are imposed by the Information Commission.

Related

Apply for RTI Assistance · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com

Official references

This article provides general information and is not legal advice. RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any government body.

Author: RTI Lawyers Editorial Team · Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026