How to Draft Strong Grounds for an RTI First Appeal?

The grounds are the heart of a First Appeal. An appeal that says “the information has not been given properly” gives the First Appellate Authority (FAA) little to decide. One that identifies each deficiency and links it to a provision of the Act is far more likely to produce a clear direction.

The short answer

Write one ground for each point of your application that was not properly answered, state what was wrong with the reply, cite the relevant section, and say what you want the FAA to direct. Keep the tone factual.

A four-part formula for each ground

  1. What was asked — “At point 2, the appellant sought certified copies of the inspection report dated …”
  2. What was replied — “The PIO replied that the information is ‘not available’.”
  3. Why it is deficient — “The report is referred to in the order dated … supplied at point 1, showing that it exists and is held by the public authority.”
  4. Relief — “The PIO may be directed to supply the report, or state on record the search made and its outcome.”

Model grounds for common situations

Situation Model ground (adapt)
No reply “No decision was received within 30 days of receipt of the application; the request stands refused under Section 7(2). Information may be directed to be supplied free of charge under Section 7(6).”
Exemption cited without reasons “The PIO has cited Section 8(1) without specifying the clause or explaining how it applies to the information sought, contrary to Section 7(8)(i).”
Blanket exemption “Even if any portion is exempt, the remaining portions can reasonably be severed and supplied under Section 10.”
Personal-information exemption “The information concerns official acts of public servants in discharge of public duties, not personal information about any individual within the meaning of Section 8(1)(j).” (Note: clause (j) was amended with effect from November 2025 and its interpretation is evolving — tailor carefully.)
“Not held” where it should be “The record is required to be maintained under [rule/order] and is referred to in [document]; a proper search has not been shown.”
Non-responsive reply “The reply states ‘matter under process’, which is not a decision on the request for copies of file notings.”
No transfer “If the information is held by another public authority, the PIO was required to transfer the request within five days under Section 6(3), which was not done.”
Public interest “The disclosure relates to [public expenditure / safety], and public interest in disclosure outweighs any harm, warranting access under Section 8(2).”

What not to include

  • New questions or information not in the original application.
  • Allegations against officers not supported by the record.
  • Long narratives of the underlying dispute.
  • Requests for action beyond the RTI Act (for example, disciplinary action by the FAA).

Order and presentation

  • Number grounds to match the points in your application.
  • Put the strongest procedural ground (deemed refusal, no reasons) first.
  • End with a consolidated relief paragraph.

Frequently asked questions

Should I cite court judgments?

It is not necessary at the First Appeal stage. Clear statutory grounds are usually enough. If you cite a decision, quote it accurately and give the full citation.

Can I raise new grounds at the Second Appeal stage?

You can develop arguments, but the information sought cannot be enlarged. Raising strong grounds at the first stage creates a better record.

Related

Apply for RTI Assistance · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com

Official references

Model grounds are illustrative only and must be adapted to your facts. This article is general information, not legal advice. RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any government body.

Author: RTI Lawyers Editorial Team · Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026