Receiving a letter that says your RTI application is “rejected” — often with nothing more than “exempted under Section 8” — is frustrating. But a rejection must meet legal requirements, and many do not. This guide explains how to assess a rejection and challenge it.
The short answer
Read the rejection carefully, identify the exact ground relied on, and check whether it is legally valid. If it is not — or if it is only partly valid — file a First Appeal under Section 19(1), generally within 30 days of receiving the rejection. In the appeal, the burden of justifying the denial lies on the PIO (Section 19(5)).
What a valid rejection must contain
Section 7(8) requires the PIO, when rejecting a request, to communicate:
- the reasons for the rejection;
- the period within which an appeal may be filed; and
- the particulars of the appellate authority.
A bare reference to “Section 8” without stating which clause and why it applies to your information is a common defect and a strong ground of appeal.
Common grounds of rejection and how to assess them
| Ground given | Questions to ask |
|---|---|
| Exempt under Section 8(1) (a)–(j) | Which clause? Does it genuinely apply to each item requested? Could non-exempt parts be supplied under Section 10? Does Section 8(2) public interest apply? |
| Personal information — Section 8(1)(j) | Since the DPDP Act amendment (in force from November 2025), clause (j) reads “information which relates to personal information”. Is the information really personal information about an individual, or is it about the public authority’s functioning? The amendment is under challenge before the Supreme Court; check the current position. |
| “Information not available / not held” | Is the record one the authority must maintain? Was it transferred under Section 6(3) if held elsewhere? |
| “Not information under Section 2(f)” — e.g. questions seeking opinions | Was your request framed as a question rather than a request for records? If so, a reworded fresh application may be better than an appeal. |
| Disproportionate diversion of resources — Section 7(9) | Section 7(9) concerns the form of access; it does not by itself justify refusing information. Can inspection be offered instead? |
| Third-party information — Section 11 | Was the third-party procedure followed (notice and decision within the period)? |
| Organisation excluded under Section 24 | Even listed intelligence and security organisations must provide information on allegations of corruption and human rights violations, subject to the conditions in Section 24. |
Step-by-step: challenging a rejection
- Note the date you received the rejection — the 30-day appeal period runs from then.
- Map the reply against each point of your application: supplied, partly supplied, refused (with which ground), or ignored.
- Draft the grounds point-wise: why the exemption does not apply, why reasons are inadequate, why severable parts should be given, and any public interest.
- State the relief: disclosure of specific points, or of severed records.
- File with the First Appellate Authority named in the rejection, online or by post, with copies of the application and rejection.
- If the FAA upholds the rejection, file a Second Appeal with the Information Commission within 90 days.
When a fresh application is better than an appeal
If the rejection is correct because your application asked for opinions, explanations or hypothetical answers, an appeal cannot enlarge or rewrite the request. A new application asking for the underlying records — file notings, orders, correspondence, reports — is often the faster route. See RTI application drafting.
Example (hypothetical)
Anil asks a State department for the file notings on the cancellation of a tender. The PIO rejects the request “under Section 8(1)(d)”. Anil’s First Appeal points out that the order gives no reasons, that the tender has been cancelled so the decision is complete, that commercial confidence cannot cover internal notings on the department’s own decision, and that any genuinely confidential bid figures can be severed under Section 10.
Documents to attach
- RTI application and proof of submission and fee.
- The rejection letter.
- Any relevant documents showing why the information is not exempt or why there is public interest.
Common mistakes
- Accepting a rejection without checking whether reasons were given.
- Arguing about the underlying grievance rather than the information.
- Missing the 30-day appeal window.
- Not asking for severable portions.
Frequently asked questions
Can the PIO reject an application because I did not give reasons?
No. Section 6(2) states that an applicant shall not be required to give any reason for requesting information.
Can a rejection be challenged directly before the Information Commission?
For an appeal seeking disclosure, the First Appeal ordinarily comes first. A complaint under Section 18 can be filed directly, but it does not lead to an order to disclose.
Need help?
We prepare First Appeals that respond to each ground of rejection. See RTI First Appeal assistance and RTI reply review.
Apply for RTI Assistance · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com
Official references
- Right to Information Act, 2005 — India Code
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any government body.
Author: RTI Lawyers Editorial Team · Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026