Before you file an RTI application — or decide what to do with a reply — an independent review can save months. RTI Lawyers reviews draft applications and PIO replies for clarity, jurisdiction, likely exemptions and procedural gaps, and tells you plainly what to change or what step to take next.
The problem
Applicants often draft their own applications, which is entirely possible under the Act. But small issues — an ambiguous question, a request for reasons rather than records, or the wrong public authority — can produce a reply that is technically compliant yet unhelpful. Equally, many applicants receive replies they are unsure about: is the exemption claimed valid, is the reply complete, and is an appeal worthwhile?
Relevant legal provisions
- Sections 2(f) and 2(j) — what counts as information, and the forms of access available (copies, inspection, certified samples, electronic form).
- Section 6 — the form of the request and transfer between authorities.
- Section 7 — time limits, deemed refusal and the contents of a rejection order.
- Sections 8 and 9 — exemptions, including clause 8(1)(j) on personal information as substituted with effect from November 2025.
- Section 10 — severability of exempt and non-exempt parts.
- Section 11 — third-party information procedure.
Two kinds of review
| Pre-filing review | Reply review |
|---|---|
| Is the right public authority addressed? | Was the reply given within the time limit? |
| Are the questions requests for records? | Does it answer each point of the application? |
| Is the scope clear (period, file, subject)? | Is any exemption explained and applicable? |
| Are likely exemptions anticipated? | Could severable parts have been supplied? |
| Are the fee and filing route correct? | Is a First Appeal, fresh application or complaint the right next step? |
How the procedure works
- Send the draft application, or the application together with the reply.
- We review against the Act and the applicable Central or State rules.
- You receive written comments, a recommended next step and, where agreed, a revised draft.
What RTI Lawyers can assist with
- Point-by-point comments on your draft.
- Assessment of the PIO’s reply and any exemption claimed.
- Recommendation: file as is, revise, file afresh, appeal, or complain.
- Follow-on drafting — applications or First Appeals.
Documents required
- Your draft application, or the filed application with proof of filing.
- The PIO’s reply and any transfer or fee letters.
- Any relevant background documents.
Professional deliverables
- Written review comments.
- A recommended next step with relevant deadlines.
- A revised draft, if included in the agreed scope.
Government fees and professional charges
A review involves no statutory fee. Any later application or appeal fee is paid to the public authority under the applicable rules. Our professional fee is confirmed after we see the documents — see Fees.
Applicable time limits
If you are reviewing a reply, remember that the First Appeal period (generally 30 days) is running. Send documents early so there is time to act.
Common mistakes we see
- Questions that seek opinions or hypothetical answers.
- Requests for another person’s personal information without addressing Section 8(1)(j).
- Accepting a bare reference to “Section 8” without asking which clause and why.
- Filing a second, identical application instead of appealing.
Frequently asked questions
Is a review necessary?
No. Many applications are filed without professional help. A review is useful where the matter is important, complex or time-sensitive.
Can you tell me whether an appeal will succeed?
We can assess the strength of the grounds, but the outcome depends on the authority or Commission and cannot be guaranteed.
Official references
- Right to Information Act, 2005 — India Code
- DoPT RTI guidance — dopt.gov.in
Related services
Request a review
Apply for RTI Assistance · Talk to a Lawyer · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com
RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with the Government of India or any State Government, Information Commission or public authority. This page provides general information, not legal advice on your specific facts. No particular response or outcome is guaranteed.
Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026