RTI First Appeal Lawyer in India – Drafting and Filing Assistance

Has your RTI application been rejected, ignored or answered with incomplete information? You may have the right to file a First Appeal under Section 19(1) of the Right to Information Act, 2005.

RTI Lawyers provides professional assistance in reviewing RTI applications, identifying appropriate grounds of appeal and preparing First Appeal documents. A well-drafted First Appeal is often the most practical way to obtain information that was wrongly withheld — and it also lays the foundation for a Second Appeal before the Information Commission if one becomes necessary.

The problem a First Appeal solves

Applicants usually come to us in one of these situations:

  • No reply was received from the Public Information Officer (PIO) within the time allowed.
  • The application was rejected, often with a bare reference to Section 8 or without reasons.
  • Information was supplied only in part, or the reply does not answer the questions asked.
  • The reply appears misleading or inconsistent with records the applicant already holds.
  • The PIO demanded an additional fee that seems unreasonable, or offered inspection instead of copies without explanation.
  • The application was transferred to another public authority and nothing further happened.

Relevant legal provisions

  • Section 7(1) — the PIO must provide the information or reject the request with reasons, normally within 30 days of receiving it (48 hours where the information concerns the life or liberty of a person).
  • Section 7(2) — if the PIO fails to decide within the time allowed, the request is deemed to have been refused.
  • Section 7(8) — a rejection must state the reasons, the period within which an appeal may be filed and the particulars of the appellate authority.
  • Section 19(1) — a person who does not receive a decision within time, or is aggrieved by the PIO’s decision, may appeal to an officer senior in rank to the PIO in the same public authority (the First Appellate Authority, or FAA).
  • Section 19(5) — in appeal proceedings, the burden of proving that a denial was justified lies on the PIO.
  • Section 19(6) — the First Appeal must normally be decided within 30 days of receipt, extendable to a total of 45 days for reasons recorded in writing.

When a First Appeal is appropriate

A First Appeal is appropriate when you want the information itself and the public authority has not supplied it properly. It is the statutory route that must ordinarily be followed before a Second Appeal can be filed with the Central or State Information Commission.

A First Appeal may not be the right step where the problem lies with the original application — for example, where it was addressed to the wrong public authority, asked for opinions rather than recorded information, or was too vague to answer. In those cases a fresh, better-framed application may serve you better. We will tell you which route is more suitable after reviewing your documents.

Time limit for filing

Situation General time limit
PIO gave a decision you are aggrieved by Within 30 days from receipt of the decision
No decision received Within 30 days from the expiry of the period within which the decision should have been given
Appeal filed after 30 days The FAA may admit it if satisfied that there was sufficient cause for the delay

Because condonation of delay is discretionary, it is safer to file within the 30-day period and to keep proof of the date of filing.

Grounds of appeal

Strong grounds are specific. Rather than stating that “the information was not given”, an effective appeal identifies, point by point, which part of the request was not answered and why the reply is legally deficient. Common grounds include:

  • Deemed refusal under Section 7(2) because no decision was given within time.
  • Rejection without reasons, contrary to Section 7(8).
  • An exemption under Section 8 invoked without explaining how it applies to the specific information.
  • Failure to consider severability under Section 10, where exempt portions could have been removed and the rest supplied.
  • Incomplete, evasive or misleading information.
  • Failure to transfer the request under Section 6(3) when the information was held by another public authority.

The First Appellate Authority

The FAA is an officer senior in rank to the PIO within the same public authority. Many public authorities publish the FAA’s name and address in their proactive disclosure under Section 4 and in their RTI reply. If the reply does not mention the FAA, we help identify the correct officer from the authority’s published information.

How the procedure works

  1. Collect your documents — the RTI application, proof of submission and fee payment, and the PIO’s reply (if any).
  2. Review — we compare the reply with each point of your application and check the dates.
  3. Drafting — we prepare the appeal with the particulars of the application and reply, the grounds, and the specific relief sought.
  4. Submission — the appeal is filed online (for Central public authorities on the RTI Online portal, where your original application was filed there) or by post or hand delivery, depending on the authority.
  5. Follow-up — we explain the FAA’s time limit and what to do if no order is passed or the order is unsatisfactory.

What RTI Lawyers can assist with

  • Review of the RTI application and the PIO’s response.
  • Identification of the correct First Appellate Authority.
  • Drafting of the First Appeal with precise grounds and relief.
  • Guidance on online or physical filing and on keeping proof of submission.
  • Advice on the next step, including a Second Appeal or a complaint, if the appeal does not resolve the matter.

Documents required

  • Copy of the RTI application (with registration number, if filed online).
  • Proof of submission and of the application fee.
  • Reply from the PIO, any transfer letter and any fee demand.
  • Any other correspondence with the public authority.
  • Your contact details for the appeal.

Professional deliverables

  • A First Appeal ready for signature and filing.
  • A short note on filing method, time limits and next steps.
  • Filing assistance, where included in the agreed scope.

Government fees and professional charges

The Central Government’s RTI rules do not prescribe a fee for filing a First Appeal; some State rules do. Any statutory fee is payable to the public authority and is separate from our professional fee. Our professional fee depends on the complexity of the matter and is confirmed to you in writing after document review — see Fees.

Common mistakes

  • Filing after the 30-day period without explaining the delay.
  • Addressing the appeal to the PIO instead of the FAA.
  • Raising new questions in the appeal that were not part of the original application.
  • Not attaching the original application and reply.
  • Failing to keep proof of the date of filing.

Frequently asked questions

Can I file a First Appeal if I received no reply at all?

Yes. Non-receipt of a decision within the time limit is itself a ground for appeal under Section 19(1), because the request is deemed to have been refused.

Do I need to attend a hearing?

Some First Appellate Authorities decide on the papers; others call the parties for a hearing. The practice varies between public authorities.

What if the FAA does not decide the appeal?

You may file a Second Appeal with the appropriate Information Commission under Section 19(3). See RTI Second Appeal assistance.

Can RTI Lawyers guarantee that the information will be supplied?

No. The public authority and, later, the Information Commission decide independently. We prepare your appeal carefully and explain the remedies available.

Official references

  • Right to Information Act, 2005 — India Code
  • RTI Online portal for Central public authorities — rtionline.gov.in
  • Department of Personnel and Training (RTI guidance) — dopt.gov.in

Related services and reading

Discuss your First Appeal

Share your RTI application and reply with us for review. You receive the scope, deliverables and professional fee before any work begins.

Apply for RTI Assistance · Talk to a Lawyer · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com

RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with the Government of India or any State Government, Information Commission or public authority. This page provides general information, not legal advice on your specific facts. No particular response or outcome is guaranteed.

Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026