The Central Information Commission (CIC) is the statutory body that hears Second Appeals and complaints concerning Central public authorities. Choosing the right remedy — a complaint under Section 18 or an appeal under Section 19 — and presenting it clearly are central to how the Commission deals with your matter. RTI Lawyers prepares complaints, appeal documents and written submissions for CIC proceedings, subject to the applicable procedure.
Complaint or appeal: the key distinction
| Complaint — Section 18 | Second Appeal — Section 19(3) | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Inquiry into specified failures of the PIO or public authority | Decision on whether the information must be supplied |
| Typical grounds | No PIO appointed or application refused; no response in time; unreasonable fee; incomplete, misleading or false information; any other matter relating to access | PIO’s and FAA’s decisions (or failure to decide) are wrong on the facts or law |
| First Appeal needed first? | No | Yes |
| Can the Commission direct disclosure? | The Supreme Court has held that it cannot on a Section 18 complaint | Yes, under Section 19(8) |
| Penalty under Section 20 | Can be considered | Can be considered |
Because a complaint does not lead to an order to supply information, an applicant who wants the information itself should ordinarily pursue the First and Second Appeal route. A complaint may be filed in addition where the conduct of the PIO calls for inquiry.
Relevant legal provisions
- Section 18(1) — grounds on which the Commission must receive and inquire into complaints.
- Section 18(2)–(4) — the Commission may initiate an inquiry and has certain powers of a civil court while doing so.
- Section 19(3) and 19(8) — Second Appeals and the Commission’s powers, including directions to provide access and award of compensation.
- Section 20 — penalty on the PIO of ₹250 per day up to ₹25,000 for specified defaults without reasonable cause, after a hearing; recommendation of disciplinary action.
- Right to Information Rules, 2012 — procedure for appeals and complaints before the CIC.
When this service is appropriate
- A Central public authority refused to accept your application or has no functioning PIO.
- Your First Appeal has been decided against you, or not decided at all.
- You received information that appears false or misleading.
- You have a CIC hearing notice and need written submissions.
- An earlier CIC order directing disclosure has not been complied with.
How the procedure works
- Assessment — complaint, appeal or both; jurisdiction (CIC or SIC); limitation.
- Drafting — facts, grounds, relief and annexure index.
- Filing — online through the CIC’s official portal or by post.
- Tracking — registration and status checks.
- Hearing — written submissions and preparation; see hearing preparation.
What RTI Lawyers can assist with
- Choosing between a complaint and an appeal.
- Drafting complaints and Second Appeals with supporting annexures.
- Written submissions, including on exemptions and penalty.
- Guidance on compliance with Commission orders.
Documents required
- RTI application, proof of submission and fee.
- PIO reply, First Appeal and FAA order (as applicable).
- Evidence of refusal, delay or misleading information.
- Any earlier Commission orders in the matter.
Professional deliverables
- Complaint and/or Second Appeal ready to file.
- Index of annexures and filing guidance.
- Written submissions where included in the agreed scope.
Government fees and professional charges
No fee is prescribed for filing a Second Appeal or complaint before the CIC under the Central rules. Our professional fee is separate and confirmed after review — see Fees.
Applicable time limits
A Second Appeal is generally filed within 90 days (Section 19(3)), with condonation possible for sufficient cause. The Act does not prescribe a specific period for complaints under Section 18, but prompt filing is advisable.
Common mistakes
- Filing only a complaint when the objective is to obtain the information.
- Approaching the CIC about a State public authority.
- Expecting the penalty amount to be paid to the applicant — a penalty is payable by the PIO to the Government; compensation under Section 19(8)(b) is a separate matter.
Frequently asked questions
Can I file both a complaint and a Second Appeal?
Yes, where the facts support both; they serve different purposes.
Will the PIO definitely be penalised?
Penalty is for the Commission to decide after hearing the PIO, who may show reasonable cause. It is not automatic.
Official references
- Right to Information Act, 2005 — India Code
- Central Information Commission — cic.gov.in
Related services and reading
Discuss your CIC matter
Apply for RTI Assistance · Talk to a Lawyer · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com
RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with the Government of India, the Central Information Commission or any public authority. No particular outcome is guaranteed.
Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026