When an Information Commission lists your Second Appeal or complaint for hearing, the hearing is often short and focused. The Commission will usually have the file, but a clear written submission and a well-organised document set help it see quickly what was asked, what was supplied and why the reply is deficient. RTI Lawyers prepares appellants and complainants for hearings before First Appellate Authorities, the Central Information Commission and State Information Commissions.
What happens at an RTI hearing
- The Commission notifies the date and mode — commonly video or audio conference at the CIC, and in person or online at State Commissions depending on their practice.
- The appellant and the public authority’s representative (often the PIO) are heard.
- The PIO explains the reply; under Section 19(5), the burden of justifying a denial lies on the PIO.
- The Commission may direct disclosure, order further search, close the matter, or issue a show-cause notice on penalty under Section 20.
Relevant legal provisions
- Section 19(5) — onus on the PIO to justify a denial.
- Section 19(8) — the Commission’s powers, including directions to provide access and award of compensation.
- Section 19(10) — the Commission decides in accordance with the prescribed procedure.
- Section 20 — penalty and disciplinary recommendations, after giving the PIO a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
- Right to Information Rules, 2012 — procedure before the CIC, including the appellant’s option to be present in person or through an authorised representative, or by video conference where available.
When this service is appropriate
- You have received a hearing notice.
- The public authority has filed a written reply you need to answer.
- Your matter involves exemptions — personal information, investigation, fiduciary relationship or commercial confidence — that need a reasoned response.
- You want to request penalty or compensation and need to set out the basis.
How the preparation works
- Review of the full record: application, replies, appeal, orders and any written reply by the public authority.
- Issue-by-issue analysis of what remains outstanding.
- Drafting of concise written submissions and an indexed document set.
- A hearing note: key points, likely questions, and the relief to request.
- Guidance on joining a video hearing and on what to do after the order.
What RTI Lawyers can assist with
- Written submissions on facts, exemptions, severability and public interest.
- Rejoinder to the public authority’s written reply.
- Submissions on penalty under Section 20 and compensation under Section 19(8)(b), where appropriate.
- Post-hearing steps, including compliance follow-up.
Documents required
- Hearing notice.
- All RTI correspondence, appeals and orders.
- Any written reply received from the public authority.
Professional deliverables
- Written submissions and indexed document set.
- One-page hearing note.
- Post-order guidance.
Professional charges
Commission hearings involve no statutory fee. Our professional fee depends on the scope (submissions only, or submissions with representation where permissible and agreed) and is confirmed in writing — see Fees.
Common mistakes
- Arguing about the underlying grievance rather than the information requested.
- Introducing new requests at the hearing.
- Not having the application and replies ready for reference.
- Missing the hearing link or time.
Frequently asked questions
Is it compulsory to attend?
Practice varies; Commissions can decide matters even if the appellant does not attend. Attending allows you to answer the PIO’s explanations.
Can someone represent me?
The CIC’s rules permit an appellant to be represented by an authorised representative. State rules may differ. We advise on what applies to your Commission.
Official references
- Right to Information Act, 2005 — India Code
- Central Information Commission — cic.gov.in
Related services and reading
- RTI Second Appeal
- CIC complaint and appeal assistance
- Hearing procedures at the Information Commission
Prepare for your hearing
Apply for RTI Assistance · Talk to a Lawyer · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com
RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any Information Commission or public authority. No particular outcome is guaranteed.
Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026