RTI Second Appeal Lawyer – CIC and State Information Commission Assistance

Has your First Appeal been rejected or not decided within the applicable period? You may have the option to approach the appropriate Information Commission through a Second Appeal under Section 19(3) of the RTI Act, 2005.

RTI Lawyers assists with the preparation and review of Second Appeal documents based on the facts, correspondence and applicable legal provisions. A Second Appeal is the stage at which an independent statutory body — the Central Information Commission (CIC) or a State Information Commission (SIC) — examines whether information was lawfully withheld.

When a Second Appeal arises

  • The First Appellate Authority (FAA) did not pass an order within the period allowed.
  • The FAA upheld the PIO’s refusal or an incomplete reply.
  • The FAA directed disclosure, but the information has still not been supplied.
  • The FAA’s order does not deal with the grounds you raised.

Relevant legal provisions

  • Section 19(3) — a second appeal lies to the Central or State Information Commission within 90 days from the date on which the decision should have been made or was actually received. The Commission may admit an appeal after 90 days if satisfied that the appellant was prevented by sufficient cause.
  • Section 19(5) — the burden of proving that a denial was justified lies on the PIO who denied the request.
  • Section 19(7) — the Commission’s decision is binding.
  • Section 19(8) — the Commission may require the public authority to provide access to information, award compensation for loss or other detriment suffered, impose penalties provided under the Act, or reject the application.
  • Section 20 — in specified defaults without reasonable cause, the Commission may impose a penalty on the PIO and recommend disciplinary action.
  • Right to Information Rules, 2012 — for appeals to the Central Information Commission, the rules prescribe the contents of the appeal and the documents to accompany it. State Information Commissions follow their own State rules.

CIC or SIC — which Commission?

Public authority Second Appeal lies to
Ministries and departments of the Government of India, central public sector undertakings, central statutory bodies, public authorities in Union Territories under the CIC’s jurisdiction Central Information Commission
State Government departments, municipal bodies, State public sector undertakings, State universities and other State public authorities The State Information Commission of that State

Filing before the wrong Commission causes delay. We check jurisdiction before drafting.

Time limit and condonation of delay

The general limitation period is 90 days. If that period has passed, the appeal should explain the reasons for the delay clearly and attach supporting material. Whether delay is condoned is for the Commission to decide; it is not automatic.

Grounds for a Second Appeal

  • The information requested falls within “information” under Section 2(f) and is held by or under the control of the public authority.
  • The exemption claimed under Section 8 or 9 does not apply, or was invoked without reasons.
  • Severable portions could have been disclosed under Section 10.
  • The PIO and FAA failed to decide within the statutory time limits.
  • The information supplied is incomplete, misleading or contrary to the record.
  • Larger public interest favours disclosure under Section 8(2), where relevant.

Contents of the appeal and documents

For appeals before the CIC, the appeal typically sets out the appellant’s name and address; the name and address of the CPIO and FAA; particulars of the orders appealed against; brief facts; the grounds; the relief sought; and a verification by the appellant. It is accompanied by copies of the RTI application, the replies and orders appealed against, documents relied upon, and an index of documents.

How the procedure works

  1. Jurisdiction and limitation check — CIC or SIC, and whether the 90-day period is running.
  2. Drafting — facts, grounds and relief, with an index of annexures.
  3. Filing — the CIC accepts second appeals online through its official portal and by post; State Commissions follow their own procedures.
  4. Tracking — the appeal receives a registration number; hearings are notified by the Commission.
  5. Hearing preparation — written submissions and a concise note for the hearing. See RTI hearing preparation.

What RTI Lawyers can assist with

  • Review of the RTI application, PIO reply, First Appeal and FAA order.
  • Jurisdiction and limitation assessment, including a request for condonation of delay where needed.
  • Drafting of the Second Appeal, annexure index and verification.
  • Guidance on online or postal filing and tracking.
  • Written submissions and hearing preparation.

Documents required

  • RTI application and proof of submission and fee.
  • PIO reply (or a note that none was received).
  • First Appeal and proof of submission.
  • FAA order (or a note that none was passed).
  • Any other relevant correspondence.

Professional deliverables

  • Second Appeal ready for signature and filing, with index of annexures.
  • Application for condonation of delay, if required.
  • Filing and tracking guidance; written submissions where included in the agreed scope.

Government fees and professional charges

The Central Government’s RTI rules do not prescribe a fee for a Second Appeal before the CIC. State rules may differ. Our professional fee is separate, depends on complexity and is confirmed in writing after document review — see Fees.

Common mistakes

  • Skipping the First Appeal stage.
  • Filing before the wrong Commission.
  • Missing the 90-day period without a reasoned delay application.
  • Expanding the request beyond the original RTI application.
  • Omitting copies of the orders under challenge.

Frequently asked questions

Can a Second Appeal be filed if the FAA never decided the First Appeal?

Yes. The 90-day period then runs from the date on which the FAA’s decision should have been made.

Is a complaint under Section 18 the same as a Second Appeal?

No. An appeal seeks a direction to supply information. A complaint asks the Commission to inquire into specified failures. The Supreme Court has held that the Commission cannot direct disclosure on a Section 18 complaint. See CIC complaint and appeal assistance.

Do I have to attend the hearing in person?

The CIC commonly conducts hearings by video or audio conferencing. Attendance practice varies between Commissions; the hearing notice explains the arrangements.

Can the outcome be guaranteed?

No. The Commission decides independently on the facts and the law.

Official references

Related services and reading

Discuss your Second Appeal

Send us your application, replies and appeal orders for review. You receive the scope and professional fee before any work begins.

Apply for RTI Assistance · Talk to a Lawyer · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com

RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with the Government of India or any State Government, Information Commission or public authority. This page provides general information, not legal advice on your specific facts. No particular response or outcome is guaranteed.

Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026