How to Challenge an Incomplete RTI Reply?

Incomplete replies are more common than outright refusals. The PIO answers three points out of seven, sends a covering letter without the attachments, or replies “information is enclosed” when nothing relevant is enclosed. The RTI Act treats incomplete information as a failure that you can challenge.

The short answer

Compare every point of your application with the reply. Then file a First Appeal under Section 19(1) within 30 days of receiving the reply, identifying exactly which points are unanswered or partly answered. Where you believe the information given is incomplete, misleading or false, you may also file a complaint under Section 18(1)(e).

Relevant provisions

  • Section 7(1) — the PIO must provide the information or reject the request (with reasons) — not simply ignore parts of it.
  • Section 7(8) — any part that is rejected must be rejected with reasons and appeal particulars.
  • Section 10 — where part of a record is exempt, the rest should be supplied after severance, with notice of the severance.
  • Section 18(1)(e) — complaint where a person believes they have been given incomplete, misleading or false information.
  • Section 19(1), (5) — appeal; burden of justifying denial on the PIO.
  • Section 20(1) — penalty where the PIO knowingly gave incomplete information without reasonable cause.

Step 1: Build a comparison table

This is the single most useful thing you can do. It turns a vague complaint into precise grounds.

Point Information sought Reply given Deficiency
1 Copy of order dated … Supplied None
2 File notings on file no. … “Matter under consideration” Not information sought; notings exist
3 Inspection report of … No reply Ignored; no reasons
4 Names of officers who … Refused, “personal information” Official designations and actions are not personal information; at minimum designations can be supplied

(Illustrative example.)

Step 2: Identify the type of deficiency

  • Silent omission — the point was simply not answered. This is a failure to decide on that point.
  • Non-responsive answer — the reply addresses something else (“the matter is under process”).
  • Missing attachments — the reply refers to enclosures that were not sent.
  • Partial supply — some pages or years supplied, others not.
  • Unexplained redaction — portions blacked out without citing Section 10 or an exemption.
  • Apparently false information — contradicted by documents you hold.

Step 3: File the First Appeal

Attach the comparison table (or set it out in the grounds). For each deficient point, state the relief: “direct the PIO to supply the inspection report sought at point 3”. Where the information was supplied late, ask for it free of charge under Section 7(6).

Step 4: Consider a complaint for misleading or false information

If you have evidence that information given is false or deliberately misleading, a complaint under Section 18(1)(e) asks the Commission to inquire and may lead to penalty proceedings. Remember that the Commission does not order disclosure on a complaint; continue the appeal route for the information itself.

Step 5: Second Appeal if needed

If the First Appellate Authority does not cure the deficiencies, file a Second Appeal within 90 days with the Central or State Information Commission.

Common mistakes

  • Writing “information is incomplete” without specifying which points.
  • Adding new questions in the appeal.
  • Filing a fresh application for the same information instead of appealing.
  • Delaying while corresponding informally with the PIO.

Frequently asked questions

Can I ask the PIO to correct the reply instead of appealing?

You can write to the PIO, but this does not stop the appeal period. File the appeal within time.

What if the PIO says the remaining information “does not exist”?

Ask in appeal whether the record is required to be maintained and whether a proper search was made. The Commission can direct a further search or an affidavit on the record’s existence, depending on its practice.

Need help?

We prepare point-by-point appeals for incomplete replies. See RTI First Appeal, reply review and complaints before the Commission.

Apply for RTI Assistance · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com

Official references

This article provides general information and is not legal advice. RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any government body.

Author: RTI Lawyers Editorial Team · Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026