Sometimes an RTI reply is not merely incomplete — it says something you know to be untrue, such as that a file “does not exist” when you hold a copy of an order from that file, or gives figures contradicted by the authority’s own published records.
The short answer
You have two remedies. To obtain correct information, file a First Appeal under Section 19(1) within 30 days. To have the PIO’s conduct examined, file a complaint under Section 18(1)(e) with the Information Commission. If the Commission finds the PIO knowingly gave incorrect, incomplete or misleading information without reasonable cause, it can impose a penalty under Section 20(1).
Relevant provisions
- Section 18(1)(e) — complaint by a person who believes they have been given incomplete, misleading or false information.
- Section 18(3) — while inquiring, the Commission has certain powers of a civil court, such as summoning persons and requiring documents.
- Section 19 — appeals, with the burden of justifying denial on the PIO.
- Section 20(1) — penalty of ₹250 per day up to ₹25,000 where the PIO knowingly gave incorrect, incomplete or misleading information, after a hearing.
- Section 20(2) — recommendation of disciplinary action.
“Wrong” versus “misleading or false”
Not every error is deliberate. Records may genuinely be missing or the PIO may have relied on another officer. The Commission will consider whether there was reasonable cause. Your complaint is stronger if you can show:
- documentary proof that contradicts the reply (an order, a receipt, a published report);
- that the PIO was told of the contradiction and did not correct it;
- a pattern — the same claim repeated across replies.
Step-by-step
- Collect evidence that the information is false or misleading.
- File the First Appeal within 30 days, explaining the contradiction and asking for the correct information.
- File a Section 18 complaint with the appropriate Commission, attaching the application, reply and contradicting evidence, and requesting an inquiry and penalty proceedings.
- If the First Appeal fails, file a Second Appeal within 90 days; you can ask the Commission to consider penalty in the appeal too.
- At the hearing, focus on the documents. See hearing preparation.
Example (hypothetical)
Sunita asks a development authority whether a building plan was approved for a neighbouring plot. The PIO replies “no plan has been sanctioned”. Sunita holds a copy of a sanction letter issued by the same authority, which she obtained from the builder. She appeals, attaching the sanction letter, and files a complaint under Section 18(1)(e). At the hearing the PIO must explain the contradiction.
Documents to keep
- RTI application, reply and proof of dates.
- Evidence contradicting the reply.
- Any correspondence pointing out the error to the PIO.
Common mistakes
- Alleging falsity without evidence.
- Filing only a complaint and expecting disclosure.
- Making allegations against officers by name beyond what the record supports.
Frequently asked questions
Can I file a criminal complaint for false RTI information?
The RTI Act provides its own remedies — appeal, complaint, penalty and disciplinary recommendation. Whether any other law applies depends on the facts; take specific advice before considering other proceedings.
Will I receive the penalty amount?
No. The penalty is payable by the PIO. Compensation for loss or detriment to the applicant is a separate power of the Commission under Section 19(8)(b).
Need help?
See CIC complaint and appeal assistance and RTI First Appeal.
Apply for RTI Assistance · Call / WhatsApp +91 9999641341 · rtilawyers@gmail.com
Official references
- Right to Information Act, 2005 — India Code
- Central Information Commission — cic.gov.in
This article provides general information and is not legal advice. RTI Lawyers is an independent private legal-services platform supported by Legal Light Consulting and is not affiliated with any government body.
Author: RTI Lawyers Editorial Team · Reviewed by RTI Lawyers Team · Last reviewed: 21 November 2026